Est. in Fulton County

Fresh from
the oven.
Curated
for the shelf.

Handcrafted breads, signature teas, and a thoughtfully selected pantry — all under one roof in the heart of McConnellsburg. Every item chosen with intention, every batch made with care.

Explore Our Offerings Find Us

Freshly baked artisan bread displayed on a wooden counter

A local favorite for artisan goods and specialty teas.

Scroll

Our Craft

Where every loaf has a story and every shelf tells yours.

Baked with Purpose

From sourdough loaves with a 48-hour ferment to buttery pastries folded by hand each morning — our bakery operates on a simple principle: nothing leaves the oven unless it's worth serving to family.

Sourdough · Croissants · Seasonal Cakes · Holiday Specials

A Curated Pantry

We don't stock everything — we stock what matters. Artisan oils, small-batch preserves, specialty flours, and an extensive tea collection sourced from growers who practice sustainable agriculture.

Loose-leaf Teas · Olive Oils · Preserves · Specialty Flours

More Than a Store

Located inside Fulton County Vintique, we're part of a community destination where quality meets connection. Whether you're picking up a morning loaf or assembling a gift basket, you'll find warmth here.

Gift Baskets · Local Collaborations · Community Events

What We Offer

From dawn to dusk, something worth savoring.

Every category is thoughtfully assembled. No fillers, no shortcuts — just genuine food and drink that makes your day a little better.

Assortment of artisan bread loaves with golden crusts

Artisan Breads

Sourdough, ciabatta, focaccia, and seasonal loaves baked fresh daily.

Loose-leaf tea varieties displayed in glass jars

Signature Teas

Loose-leaf blends, single-origin teas, and herbal infusions from around the world.

Fresh pastries and desserts arranged on a display counter

Pastries & Sweets

Croissants, tarts, cakes, and holiday specialties made from scratch every morning.

Curated pantry items including oils, preserves, and specialty ingredients

Pantry & Gifts

Small-batch preserves, artisan oils, specialty flours, and curated gift baskets.

48hr

Sourdough Fermentation

Daily

Fresh Baked Goods

100%

Artisan & Natural

Fulton

County Community

Warm interior of Tickle Your Fancy bakery and grocery with wooden shelves and baked goods

Our Story

Rooted in McConnellsburg, crafted with intention.

Tickle Your Fancy lives inside Fulton County Vintique on Lincoln Way — a place where quality food and thoughtful curation meet in a space that feels like home.

We started with a simple conviction: that people deserve access to genuinely good bread, exceptional teas, and pantry items they can trust — without needing to drive into the city. Every product on our shelves has been tried, tested, and approved by our team.

Whether you're a longtime resident or just passing through south-central Pennsylvania, we invite you to slow down, browse the shelves, and discover something that makes your table a little more special.

Handcrafted Daily

Locally Proud

Community Focused

Visit Us

Come say hello.

We're located in the heart of McConnellsburg, right on Lincoln Way. Stop by for a loaf, a cup of tea, or a browse through the pantry.

Location

Fulton County Vintique
225 Lincoln Way W
McConnellsburg, PA 17233-1304

Phone

(717) 496-5948

Call ahead for custom orders

Email

tickleyourfancytea@gmail.com

We respond within 24 hours

Hours

Tuesday – Saturday
10:00 AM – 5:00 PM
Sunday & Monday: Closed

Send Us a Message

Have a question, want to place a custom order, or just want to say hi? We'd love to hear from you.

Your Name

Email Address

Subject

Message

Street view of McConnellsburg, Pennsylvania along Lincoln Way

Find Us

225 Lincoln Way W
McConnellsburg, PA

Right in the heart of downtown, inside Fulton County Vintique. Look for the warm light and the smell of fresh bread.

Get Directions (717) 496-5948

Fresh from the oven. Curated for the shelf.